Late in the evening of the first of July the Williamite army, better trained and equipped, began to take control. King James and his army retreated to Dublin through the Pass of Duleek. They were finally defeated at Aughrim in 1691. That defeat decided the fate of Catholicism in Ireland with the introduction of the penal laws. In 1746 in Culloden, Scotland's Catholic hopes were finally extinguished with the massacre on the return of "Bonnie Prince Charles."